We Were Liars is an intriguing psychological mystery-drama that combines romance, family conflict and dark secrets in a beautiful but increasingly unsettling summer setting. Released on Prime Video in June 2025, the series is based on E. Lockhart’s bestselling 2014 novel of the same name. It stars Emily Alyn Lind as Cadence “Cady” Sinclair, alongside Esther McGregor as Mirren, Shubham Maheshwari as Gat and Joseph Zada as Johnny. Together, the four characters form the close-knit group known as “the Liars.”
The story follows 17-year-old Cadence, a member of the extremely wealthy Sinclair family, who spends her summers on her grandfather’s private island in New England. After suffering a mysterious accident that leaves her struggling with memory loss, Cady returns to the island determined to discover what happened to her. However, her family refuses to discuss the incident, and even the people closest to her appear to be keeping secrets. As Cady slowly pieces together fragments of her memories, she begins questioning the seemingly perfect family life surrounding her.
Emily Alyn Lind gives a strong performance as Cady, successfully portraying the character’s confusion, vulnerability and determination. Because the mystery is largely experienced from Cady’s perspective, Lind has the difficult job of keeping viewers emotionally invested while withholding important information. Her performance makes Cady’s search for answers feel personal rather than simply serving as a mystery for the audience to solve.
The chemistry between the four young leads is another major strength. Esther McGregor brings warmth and personality to Mirren, Joseph Zada gives Johnny an energetic presence, and Shubham Maheshwari delivers a thoughtful performance as Gat. Their friendship provides many of the series’ lighter moments.
The private-island setting is particularly effective. Beautiful beaches, enormous houses and luxurious summer gatherings create an idyllic atmosphere, but the series gradually reveals the tension beneath the Sinclair family’s polished appearance. Their wealth and privilege cannot protect them from jealousy, resentment and long-held secrets. This contrast between beautiful surroundings and darker family problems gives the show much of its distinctive atmosphere.
We Were Liars is an absorbing and emotional mystery that successfully mixes teenage romance with complicated family drama and psychological suspense. Strong performances from Emily Alyn Lind, Esther McGregor, Shubham Maheshwari and Joseph Zada help bring the central friendship to life, while the secrets surrounding the Sinclair family keep the story engaging. Although the pacing may feel slow at times, viewers who enjoy mysterious coming-of-age dramas filled with wealth and family secrets should find plenty to enjoy.
RATINGS:
IMDb: 6.8/10
Rotten Tomatoes: 64%
StreamTV: